Supreme Court Decision Confirms ATM Sites in Supermarkets and Convenience Stores are Not Separately Rateable

22 May 2020

Share this

The Supreme Court issued its long awaited decision on the rateability of ATM sites on Wednesday. The decision agreed with the Court of Appeal that the sites of cash machines at supermarkets and convenience stores are not separately rateable but rather form an integral part of the stores they serve.

The dispute has run through the Valuation Tribunal, the Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber) and the Court of Appeal.   The Court of Appeal decision was appealed by the Valuation Office Agency .

In essence the decision had regard to the situation where both the retailer and the ATM operator derive a commercial benefit from the use of the site.  The Supreme Court decided that where the retailer had conferred rights on the operator to further the retailer’s own general business purposes, then the retailer retained occupation of the ATM site for both internal and external ATM’s, and a separate assessment on the ATM site is incorrect.

The Supreme Court therefore dismissed the Valuation Office Agency’s appeal.

The decision is important in curtailing the VOA’s quest to create additional assessments.   Crucially, it will also enable ATM operators to continue to offer their facilities, particularly in socially disadvantaged locations where the need is greatest and the commercial viability of the ATM is marginal.

Mansford has expanded its investment portfolio over the last few years. Over this time Andrew West has provided us with a full rating valuation service which has involved giving a view on liabilities prior to acquisitions, as well as conducting negotiations with Valuation Officers on our UK estate. The portfolio includes a wide range of properties from shops, offices and pubs to major leisure schemes. He has been particularly successful in mitigating our liabilities to empty property rate, which has been an issue on acquisition prior to implementing our development and letting strategy. I have no hesitation in recommending Andrew's expertise in rating valuation for all property types. The profile of property within his portfolio and the successes achieved are testament to his position as an extremely accomplished rating practitioner.

Leopold Hall, Partner, Mansford LLP